Project ≠ Program ≠ Portfolio ≠ Strategy

13. Dezember 2020
Kategorien
Newsletter abonnieren

Project ≠ Program ≠ Portfolio ≠ Strategy

I have had many heated discussions around these terms. People mix these up and it confuses your organization and its people. 

This is my take on it. 

If your organization is running many projects at the same time it is impossible to make the right decisions if all projects are performed in isolation. Therefore projects are managed in logical groups to use resources efficiently and effectively. 

There are two kinds of such groups. Programs and portfolios.

The distribution of projects under a program or portfolio depends on the nature and the type of project. Programs are managed through program management and portfolios are managed through portfolio management.

Let’s start with the diagram below. It shows very clearly the relationship between the three P’s of Project Management.

Three P's of Project Management

Project

A project is the lowest level in the hierarchy of project, program, portfolio, and organization.

According to the PMBOK Guide, “A project is a temporary endeavour undertaken to create a unique product, service or result.”

So, you can say that the nature of a project is temporary; once the project achieves its objective, it no longer exists, and the objective of the project is to create a unique product, or develop a system to provide you with a service or the result.

Project management is the application of people, process, technology, knowledge, and skills to achieve successful completion of specific project goals and objectives.

Good project management means teams and team members are constantly developing and improving, giving the business a competitive advantage. Good projects are typically short and fat.

Program

A program is a group of related projects and program activities managed to contribute to the same business objective or benefit. The program as a whole has clearly defined goals, and each project within the program assists in meeting those goals. 

So please do not call a large project a program. It is not.

Program management allows your organization to have the ability to align multiple projects for optimized or integrated costs, schedule, effort, and benefits. 

Program managers look at cross-project dependencies, risks, issues, requirements, and solutions, and may coordinate with individual project managers to achieve these insights and keep the overall program healthy. They’re less concerned with the success of every single individual project, and more focused on the success of the overall initiative and achieving the larger benefit. 

Program managers are also concerned with making sure the right projects are chosen or prioritized in order to achieve the most business value. Successful programs work towards improvements that will have a long-term impact on your organization, and unlike projects that have a specific end date, programs may be ongoing initiatives.

Portfolio

Portfolio is a collection of projects, programs, and sub-portfolios managed as a group to achieve strategic objectives. All these items may not necessarily be interdependent or directly related. 

For example your organization has different investments, products or services, but has a global strategy to maximize the ROI. The four goals of portfolio management are:

1) Maximizing the value of your portfolio

2) Seeking the right balance of projects

3) Creating a strong link to your strategy

4) Doing the right number of projects

Portfolio management provides a big picture of your organization’s projects and programs and supports leadership to analyse and make the right decisions.

Project management is about executing projects right, portfolio management is about executing the right projects. It is a way to bridge the gap between strategy and execution.

Strategy

As stated before, a portfolio is a collection of projects, programs, and sub-portfolios, managed as a group to achieve strategic objectives. So it comes naturally that for each strategy there exists a portfolio to achieve this strategy. This is reflected in the diagram below.

Strategy Execution through Project Portfolio Management

This also means that if you only have one strategy you should manage all your projects in one portfolio.

In a nutshell: A project is focused on creating a unique product, service, or result. A program is a collection of projects that need to be managed and coordinated together. And, a portfolio is a collection of projects and programs that are managed as a group to achieve strategic goals and a business value.

Tags

Das könnte Sie auch interessieren

The Five Elements of a Strong Governance Structure for Critical Projects

16. Januar 2025

Every executive has nightmares about that project—the one that spirals into an unmitigated disaster.  In general there are four ways a project can end up in a boardroom-shaking failure that can destroy value, reputations, and trust in one fell swoop. 1. The Titanic Failure: The project chugs along, oblivious to the iceberg ahead, burning millions

Weiterlesen

Why Every Critical Project Needs Independent Reviews

14. Januar 2025

«Trust, but verify.» That timeless adage applies as much to critical projects as it does to diplomacy. Without an independent review, even the best-run projects can veer off course, leaving organizations blindsided by delays, cost overruns, or outright failures. Here’s the uncomfortable truth: internal stakeholders are often too close to the project to see the

Weiterlesen

Why Every Critical Project Needs an Executive Sponsor

13. Januar 2025

Launching a critical project without an executive sponsor is like sending a ship to sea without a captain—good luck steering through the storm. Projects don’t fail because of bad intentions. They fail because of a lack of alignment, authority, and support.  That’s where the executive sponsor steps in—not just as a figurehead but as the

Weiterlesen

Why Every Critical Project Needs a Dedicated Project Manager

12. Januar 2025

Far too often, organizations assign critical projects to people who already have full-time roles or, worse, delegate management to a loosely organized team with no single point of accountability. The results? Missed deadlines, blown budgets, and a whole lot of finger-pointing. Here’s the hard truth: if the project is important, it deserves a dedicated project

Weiterlesen

Case Study 21: The Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) $250 Million CHESS Blunder

6. Januar 2025

The Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) embarked on an ambitious journey to replace its 25-year-old Clearing House Electronic Subregister System (CHESS) with a state-of-the-art, blockchain-based platform.  Initially envisioned as a groundbreaking project to enhance efficiency, security, and scalability, the CHESS replacement project quickly turned into a cautionary tale.  The initiative faced repeated delays and escalating costs

Weiterlesen

Project Recovery

2. Januar 2025

  Projects fail for a variety of reasons. Especially technology projects have a low success rate. Typically more than half of them are considered a failure. If your current in-house or outsourced software or web development project is off track, chances are I can bring the necessary input and expertise to get the job done. Troubled projects

Weiterlesen

When $100 Million Technology Projects Fail, It’s the Board’s Fault—Every Single Time

2. Januar 2025

In Switzerland, rumors suggest that both Bank Julius Bär and Raiffeisen Schweiz are grappling with failed technology projects, each costing over $100 million so far. Bank Julius Bär is reportedly trying to replace its existing core banking system for the Swiss booking center with Temenos, while Raiffeisen Schweiz is attempting to build a modern e-banking

Weiterlesen

10 Essential Questions Every Board Should Ask About Technology

16. Dezember 2024

Board members play an important role in steering organizations through the complexities of technology initiatives.  To fulfil this role effectively, it’s essential to ask the right questions that probe the strategic, operational, and risk aspects of technology projects.  Here are ten critical questions every board should consider: 1) How does this technology initiative align with

Weiterlesen

Independent Board Advisory

16. Dezember 2024

Effective boards provide clarity, governance, and oversight to steer organizations toward success. However, large technology initiatives, digital transformations, and innovation efforts often challenge even the most seasoned boards.  My Board Advisory service empowers boards and board members to navigate the complexities of modern technology decisions with confidence and precision. As a trusted advisor and experienced

Weiterlesen

Case Study 20: The $4 Billion AI Failure of IBM Watson for Oncology

7. Dezember 2024

In 2011, IBM’s Watson took the world by storm when it won the television game show Jeopardy!, showcasing the power of artificial intelligence (AI). Emboldened by this success, IBM sought to extend Watson’s capabilities beyond trivia to address real-world challenges.    Healthcare, with its complex data and critical decision-making needs, became a primary focus. Among

Weiterlesen
Next